Speechless

18
Jun
2009

Just ran across the story of a Minnesota woman who was “fined” 1.92 MILLION (yes that is NOT a typo) for illegally downloading 24 songs (again not a typo). Can someone please inject some common sense in to this whole digital music debate? What we’re saying is that downloading a .99 cent item is worth this? If I walk in to the Family Dollar and steal 24 items, should I owe the dollar store millions? This whole thing is insanity personified. If I don’t pay 24 dollars in taxes, do I owe the government 1.92 million in fines? Absolutely asinine.

10 response about Speechless »

  1. Is there a worse crime against humanity than downloading music? I think not.

    Comment by mike rot — June 19, 2009

  2. I heard this on NPR this morning. The woman's quote as she left the courthouse was, “good luck getting [the money] from me.” Ha! I almost WANT to be charged for illegal dowloading music. I have so many things to say to the coke-sniffing record company execs it would be comical.

    Comment by Andrew James — June 19, 2009

  3. To expand the dollar store argument – if you steal from the dollar store, you've stolen product that they then can't sell. Tangible loss. If you steal music by downloading, there's no tangible loss. There's potential loss of a purchase that you may or may not have made, as well as potential gain of purchases that you may make in the future (I've spent way more money on concerts and CDs of bands I found out about by downloading than I ever did before I started downloading).

    Comment by Jandy — June 19, 2009

  4. testing disqus

    Comment by mike rot — June 19, 2009

  5. Did it work? :)

    Comment by Jandy — June 19, 2009

  6. if you can read this it works fine

    Comment by mike rot — June 19, 2009

  7. Hey! Look at that. I'm actually signed in. Must've been a password issue.

    Comment by Andrew_James — June 19, 2009

  8. Test comment

    Comment by Andrew James — June 19, 2009

  9. just testing Andrew’s theory out, ignore.

    Comment by mike — June 19, 2009

  10. What an incredible waste of time. We should actually be really upset about this. Gov't time and money was spent on prosecution of this? What the hell for? Is this going to curb illegal downloading or pirating? I would bet money that this lady is sitting at home right now pondering on whether or not to download the latest “Seal” album. This did nothing but waste time and money and get me even more excited to steal product from the record company.

    Comment by Andrew James — June 19, 2009

Leave a comment

Name
Email
Web Site

Recent Comments

  • LOST – Season 6 Discussion Thread (23)
    • Rusty James: http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0 ,,20313460_20339244_4,00.html This article by Jensen (at EW) is the best...
    • Ross Miller: (Sorry, posted this in the wrong – season 5 discussion – thread) Hey, you guys seen this?...
    • Ross Miller: THIS COMMENT MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS ************** LOST DISCUSSION ************** RECENT COMMENTS BUFFER...
    • Rusty James: @ And BTW, does anyone have any idea what Dogen said in Japanese after Lennon asked why the water wasn’t...
    • Ross Miller: THIS COMMENT MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS ************** LOST DISCUSSION ************** RECENT COMMENTS BUFFER...
    • Rusty James: THIS COMMENT MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS ************** LOST DISCUSSION ************** RECENT COMMENTS BUFFER...
    • rot: THIS COMMENT MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS ************** LOST DISCUSSION ************** RECENT COMMENTS BUFFER...
    • Rusty James: THIS COMMENT MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS ************** LOST DISCUSSION ************** RECENT COMMENTS BUFFER...
    • rot: THIS COMMENT MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS ************** LOST DISCUSSION ************** RECENT COMMENTS BUFFER...
    • Ross Miller: THIS COMMENT MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS ************** LOST DISCUSSION ************** RECENT COMMENTS BUFFER...
  • What I’ve Been Reading Lately: February 2010 Edition (3)
    • Jonathan B.: Larry from The Razor’s Edge has to be one of my favorite literacy characters. I really connected...
    • rot: Razor’s Edge and Down and Out were pretty awesome. I usually don’t like Maugham, find his style...
    • murph: i read THE GRAVEYARD BOOK recently. great story for ALL ages. big Neil Gaiman fan, read all of his work and...
  • Details on New Broken Social Scene Album (4)
    • Big Scott: I second that BSS were awesome at Lolla a couple years back. I went from the relaxing sounds of BSS over...
    • Andrew James: Totally. I HATE repetitive songs, but its ironic that it’s almost as repetitive as it gets and I...
    • Jandy Stone: You mean because it’s TOTALLY AWESOME? I’m listening to a BSS playlist right now, and I...
    • Michael W. May: Anthems For A Seventeen Year Old Girl has been popping up on best of the decade lists, btw (and for...
  • LOST – Season 5 Discussion Thread (577)
    • Ross Miller: Hey, you guys seen this? http://www.newsweek.com/id/402 11#?l=1785302026&t=6473561 1001 It’s a...
  • Mass Effect 2 Final Launch Trailer (10)
    • Jandy Stone: David, totally agree. I spent like three days doing nothing but playing this when it came out. Now...
    • David Brook: I bought this last weekend and yes, it’s really bloody good. They’ve toned down a lot of the...